Baseball’s “Did That Really Happen?” Quiz

By /

Weird MLB Stats have given baseball some of its most jaw-dropping, head-scratching, and downright hilarious moments. From record-smashing rookies to teams setting marks no one thought possible, the diamond has always been home to the unexpected. But how well do you really know the quirkiest feats in MLB history?

This “Did That Really Happen?” trivia quiz will challenge your knowledge of bizarre records, unbelievable streaks, and moments so strange they’re almost forgotten. Whether you’re a stathead who lives for the numbers or a casual fan who loves the fun side of baseball, this quiz is the ultimate test of your weird baseball IQ.

So… are you ready to step up to the plate? Or will these wild stats leave you looking silly at bat?

Take the Baseball’s “Did That Really Happen?” Quiz now!

Baseball’s “Did That Really Happen?” Quiz

1 / 12

What is the MLB record for most stolen bases in a season, and who holds it?

2 / 12

Who became the Mets' all-time home run leader in August 2025?

3 / 12

Which pitcher famously threw a no-hitter while reportedly high on LSD?

4 / 12

Which two teams are tied for most regular-season wins in MLB history?

5 / 12

Who hit a historic home run off a 103.9 mph pitch—the fastest ever homered off since Statcast began?

6 / 12

Which “unbreakable” record involves a 26-inning marathon game that ended in a 1–1 tie?

7 / 12

What controversial equipment sparked a power surge for the Yankees in 2025?

8 / 12

In 2024, which team scored 14 runs in one inning on Opening Day, a new MLB record?

9 / 12

Which team set a modern MLB record for total hits in a three-game series?

10 / 12

In 2025, what became the worst 50-game start (by record) in modern MLB history?

11 / 12

How many streaks of 10 consecutive seasons with 200+ hits does MLB history contain, not just who, but the number of players?

12 / 12

Which player in 2024 became the first in MLB history to record five extra-base hits in his first two career games?

Your score is

The average score is 91%

0%

How Did You Do?

Knocked it out of the park or struck out looking? Drop your score in the comments and let us know if you’re a true stat junkie. Then tag a fellow baseball fanatic and see if they can top your score!

Love Sports Talk? Find Us Here:

Spotify
iHeartRadio
YouTube

Follow us on social media: Threads | Instagram

Scroll to Top